Guest Commentary on the Science of Suicide

-
When my friend posted this on Facebook, it was an “a-ha!” moment for me. This has been reposted with her permission. Shauna is a psychiatric mental health nurse practitioner and she is one of the smartest and most compassionate people I know.

“On the heels of another suicide, the hanging death of a local mother, I feel compelled to share something about the science of suicide. Too often, I have heard or read comments suggesting that the suicide victim was selfish or did not consider her own family, etc. How I educate patients about this serious topic is to liken suicide to having a heart attack. For example, we know the risks for Coronary Artery Disease: smoking, obesity, hypertension, hyperlipidemia, yet a heart attack doubtless feels surprising to its sufferer. Suicide is a lot like this. We know the risks: depression, substance abuse, risk-taking, history of other aggressions, etc yet the great deficiency in serotonin (a happy neurotransmitter or brain chemical implicated in both depression and anxiety) actually happens quite precipitously. How do we know this? We can measure levels of serotonin metabolites in the cerebral spinal fluid and we find that, in individuals who have completed suicide, their levels are much lower than in individuals simply struggling with depression. And there is no difference in serotonin metabolites of the lightly depressed versus the seriously depressed. These dangerously low levels of serotonin mean that not only do we have despondency and despair but also poor impulse control. What a lethal combination. 

Individuals who have survived high lethality suicide attempts (jumping off the Golden Gate bridge, shooting themselves in the head) mostly remark that they ‘did not know what they were thinking’ and allude to being ‘not in [their] right mind.’ Obviously, individuals affected by mental illness have serious problems thinking clearly.

Kant believed that suicide was *the* philosophical problem. (He was very punitive and unforgiving in his view). Certainly, I empathize with individuals not being able to ‘understand’ suicide, but what I would definitely encourage would be to at least try.”


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Per “Dead” Ohlin (January 16, 1969 – April 8, 1991)

-
Image
Born Per Yngve Ohlin (sometime was referred to by friends and family as Pelle), he was later known for his stage name, Dead. Ohlin was born in Stockholm, Sweden and suffered from sleep apnea as a child. There are varying accounts as to how his spleen ruptured when he was 10 years old; some sources state he was in an ice skating accident and other suggest that the cause was from being beaten so horribly due to bullying at school. Regardless of how it occurred, he was taken to the hospital and was for some time clinically dead. The incident greatly affected him afterwards as he became obsessed with death and dying. It has been suggested that Ohlin had a rare mental disorder called Cotard’s Syndrome, in which the afflicted person believes they literally or figuratively dead; in Ohlin’s case this most likely stemmed from the trauma he experienced. Ohlin struggled with depression throughout his short life, which caused him to withdraw further into himself and display behavior t...
Read more

Dave Rubinstein (September 5, 1964 – July 3, 1993)

-
Image
Dave Rubinstein grew up in Forest Hills, Queens and co-founded the punk band Reagan Youth along with his friend Paul Bakija, who played guitar. They both attended the same high school in Queens (Forest Hills High School) as the Ramones did. Rubinstein later became better known for his stage name, Dave Insurgent.   After graduating high school, Reagan Youth released their first EP and toured the US with bands such as the Dead Kennedy’s, Beastie Boys, The Misfits, and Bad Brains on the Rock Against Racism tour. They were an influential band in the NY punk and hardcore scene and regularly performed at CBGB’s, even when they were still in high school.   Their music was sarcastic and political; they used KKK and Nazi Party imagery on their albums and sometimes wore authentic uniforms from the two hate groups on stage. Rubinstein was quite vocal about his views about being anti-racist and anti-fascist. Several members of Rubinstein’s family were holocaust survivors. ...
Read more

Jeff Ward (November 18, 1962 – March 19, 1993)

-
Image
Originally from Chicago, Jeff Ward drummed for a number of bands including the Revolting Cocks, Nine Inch Nails, Lard, Ministry, and Low Pop Suicide. Ward grew up with a family of musicians. His brother Jason played bass and his father was also a drummer.   While living in Phoenix he was in a metal band called Coven of Thieves, which he joined a year before his death.   According to Dan McGuinness, Coven’s lead singer, Ward was frustrated with how he was treated in the music industry. “Jeff wasn’t the kind of guy who would hold a grudge against people; he would still show up and play on a session if he was asked. But he’d say, ‘I can’t believe I have to call and ask for royalties.’ That was a big thing for him: that he would have to track people down just to get paid. I think it’s kind of indicative of the music business in general. It’s the kind of business that can eat you alive.”   Ward struggled with heroin addiction and became discouraged over his inabili...
Read more